Friday, November 2, 2007

Age Verification - The Residents Strike Back

Walking around SL earlier on I was given an item by an anti age-verification group I'm a member in. The item is called Agelock, and it works by combining a security orb type script with an offsite reference script.

Visitors to land with Agelock running on it will have their names scanned against a database Agelock keep, which contains just three pieces of information about an avatar. Their name, their date of birth and the magical checkbox they've agreed to check that says "Yes, I'm over 18." If they refuse to give this information, they'll be asked to leave. If they haven't left within two minutes the security orb part of the script will cut in and eject them using the teleport home option.

This again shifts responsibility to the individual avatar, rather than the land owner, and asks for nothing more than the same kind of "good faith" agreement that has been held binding for viewing adult content sites on the web.

As such, I think it's a good idea. I also think that Linden Labs won't go for it. Or at least won't abandon their own plans to use Aristotle/Integrity for age verification.

And I do still have a real issue with Aristotle/Integrity. For a start, I can see a million ways I could cheat the system. I hold a photocard license within Canada, but because of a change of address I actually have two licenses. And when they changed my address they failed to put the correct information on the new address, but since misaddressed mail gets put on the windowsill in my apartment block to be sent back in bulk by management, I still picked up the new license even though the details on it are wrong.

According to their site, the information required in Canada is first name, last name, date of birth, postcode and telephone number. Well, let's see now. I can go out to a store, buy a prepay phone and give false details to activate it, so that's no proof. I can make up a first name and last name, so that's no proof, and as long as my DOB is convincing how do they check it? As well, since I recently moved and could quite easily use my old postcode (even assuming I didn't use the net to look up a valid postcode and use that) so those details could be false too.

Which essentially leaves them with the checkbox that I effectively ticked when I agreed that yes, I was over 18 so they could go ahead and verify me. All the other details might be false. What kid do YOU know that can't worm that information out of an adult given the opportunity?

What I AM providing with the Aristotle/Integrity method is statistics for them to sell to political entities, who could use them anyway they damn well please. All I'm effectively doing for Linden Labs is allowing someone else to say "She's telling the truth" - which itself, to me, implies that Linden Labs by default will assume I'm a liar, this despite the fact that they have my credit card information and have successfully billed it in the past.

There is effectively no difference in the information Agelock is asking and the information Aristotle is asking, except Aristotle ask for much more information and advertise that they collect this specifically to sell to political entities. I would be extremely surprised if with my recent immigration and the chaos that the lost paperwork entailed, Aristotle/Integrity could get a perfect answer on me... but I'm certainly not willing to give them an opportunity to then sell that information to the highest political bidder.

To close, let me link a video that is actually published by Integrity for the purposes of drumming up business selling the information they are planning to use Linden Labs to collect. It's quite frightening just how much they are prepared to pimp out the information they get.

Agelock is a nice system, but I can't see LL using it. Integrity is not. Judge for yourself if you think your information is safe with them.

Thursday, November 1, 2007

Still alive / pet peeves

Yes, sorry about that folks, but I'm still here.

And I finally got my email working again. You can email me at my first name @ e-c-t.ca - there, spammers, try and work THAT one out! This does mean, of course, that you NEED my first name to send me email... but then those that know me, know what it is.

I was talking to someone in SL earlier on today, and they asked me my one biggest peeve about other people in SL. I had to think about it for a time, but I did find something jumped out and hit me.

As those of you who know me realise, I am a roleplayer. I consider myself a good one, too. Which made me thought of something that always makes me role my eyes. I've never understood it.

Why some roleplayers seem to NEVER use the /me command.

MSN has it. Second Life has it. Hell, even the parlour chatroom has it. Most IM'ers use it without a second thought, especially if they've used IRC at all. I use it all the time, finding that it adds more (IMHO) to a roleplaying scene to see "Untameable Wildcat looks surprised" Than "Name: I look surprised" To me, that breaks the realism of the scene. When I'm on SL I like to some extend to BE Untameable Wildcat. She's a reflection of my Geminiic personality and therefore fun to play... so why - and this seems especially true for guys who want sex - do people lack the ability to use the /me command?

In the old days of paper and pencil roleplay, admittedly one had to use the first person when they spoke to the GM about their character - but this is the internet, it's kind of more advanced... surely if you can work out how to sit on a poseball, you can work out how to use the /me command and talk in the third person. It ain't rocket science. Being able to pose realistically in text, not just with poseballs should be a fundamental part of good roleplaying. You should master it if you're going to call yourself a roleplayer. Not doing so is my pet peeve of the month.

Thursday, August 2, 2007

It's live, and its... broken

Voice Chat is now live in SL.

It recognizes the existence of my Logitech USB microphone on my XP-running desktop, but doesn't seem able to use it. I click to test and nothing. Completely dead. I've checked that it's the default input device in control panel, and I know it works because Skype is quite happy with it... but SL doesn't work with it at all.

My bang up to date laptop came with Vista (ugh) - guess what... SL's voice chat doesn't work with that either. I know for a FACT that this works, because Teamspeak - which I use for World of Warcraft - is happy with both systems.

So well done again Linden Labs. You know a feature is live when it's broken.

Monday, July 30, 2007

Scenes from something resembling real life...

So there I was, at the Tim Horton's coffee shop, sitting at the table drinking coffee and leaching off the nearby Wifi hotspot.

The staff couldn't quite believe their eyes.

Real me
Sitting in a real Tim Hortons
Drinking Real Coffee

looking at a laptop where
Virtual me
was sitting in a virtual Tim Hortons
drinking virtual coffee.

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Vote for my bug!

Please vote for this bug in the SL Jira

The other day when SL was experiencing major problems due to the power outage problems that happened in their area, I lost something from my inventory which originally cost me in total, around L$2,500 (including the additional scripts)

The problem occurred because the item was set nocopy, a not uncommon occurrence when you buy something from a vendor, and it occurs because of the way SL deals with rezzing items.

Currently, when you drag an item from your inventory into the world, SL removes the item (if it's nocopy) or a copy of the item (if it's not nocopy) from your inventory, then it attempts to rez that item inworld. The difficulty comes when the asset server is on the fritz, because then the error "failed to rez item" is dealt with after the item has been removed from your inventory. If that item was nocopy, then it is lost. Permanently.

If LL (or an enterprising open source programmer) were to change this around so that errors rezzing the item in world are checked for before the item or copy of the item is removed from the avatar's inventory, and if an error is detected abort removing it from the inventory, then people would not suffer inventory loss in this way.

Simple perhaps... but it doesn't appear to have been thought of. Please go to the Jira using the link above (you may need to use your SL avatar name to log in) and use the voting link on the lower left of your screen to vote for this issue to be resolved.

Thank you.

Sunday, June 3, 2007

Where does the line get drawn?

On Thursday after normal office hours, Daniel Linden posted the following:


The diversity of things to see and do within Second Life is almost unimaginable, but our community has made it clear to us that certain types of content and activity are simply not acceptable in any form. Real-life images, avatar portrayals, and other depiction of sexual or lewd acts involving or appearing to involve children or minors; real-life images, avatar portrayals, and other depictions of sexual violence including rape, real-life images, avatar portrayals, and other depictions of extreme or graphic violence, and other broadly offensive content are never allowed or tolerated within Second Life.

Please help us to keep Second Life a safe and welcoming space by continuing to notify Linden Lab about locations in-world that are violating our Community Standards regarding broadly offensive and potentially illegal content. Our team monitors such notification 24-hours a day, seven-days a week. Individuals and groups promoting or providing such content and activities will be swiftly met with a variety of sanctions, including termination of accounts, closure of groups, removal of content, and loss of land. It’s up to all of us to make sure Second Life remains a safe and welcoming haven of creativity and social vision.


This makes a disturbing ambiguity which really needs to be closed up. Especially worrying is his term "other broadly offensive content" which is neither defined nor elaborated on. Who defines what is "broadly offensive" and what is not, and where do Linden Labs stand on such a matter? If the owner of a banline using plot of land or sim decides that nude pictures of his avatar in compromising situations with another avatar is fine, or a picture of a nude real life model is fine, where do Linden Labs stand if someone disables their camera constraints to look into the sim and reports the content?

I'd very much like Daniel Linden - or any other responsible Linden - to say who would be responsible and what action might be taken under the following circumstances.
  1. Open land, no group, no banlines. The land owner places a large image taken from the internet of two nude adults engaged in a sexual act. Is this unacceptable and if so, who gets punished and what would be the punishment? (I figured I'd start off with an easy one)
  2. Open land, no group, no banlines. A visiting avatar places a large image taken from the internet of two nude adults engaged in a sexual act. Is this unacceptable and if so, who gets punished and what would be the punishment?
  3. Group land, banlines for anyone not in the group. The land owner places a large image taken from the internet of two nude adults engaged in a sexual act. Is this unacceptable and if so, who gets punished and what would be the punishment?
  4. Group land, banlines for anyone not in the group. A Group Member places a large image taken from the internet of two nude adults engaged in a sexual act. Is this unacceptable and if so, who gets punished and what would be the punishment?
  5. A shopping mall, with an item vendor selling a BDSM item. The vendor has an image of a furry or human avatar trapped within the item, portrayed in an obviously uncomfortable or painful position. Does the owner of the vendor commit an offense meriting punishment? Does the owner of the mall also commit an offense for not returning the vendor? Could either be banned over it?
  6. Open sim, free to join group, privately owned island. A visiting avatar leaves a prim decorated with underage sexual images, but sets it to group ownership so that it won't be autoreturned. Would just the avatar concerned be subject to action, or would the island sim owner also be subject to action for not discovering and returning the item?
  7. This one's a doozy. Open sim, free to join group, privately owned island. A visiting avatar leaves prims containing explicit pictures of children being raped or tortured while the owner of the island/sim is away (on vacation for example). The content is reported to Linden Labs who then pass the blame to the sim owner and send an email instructing him to remove the content and/or ban the avatar that placed it. The owner, being on vacation and therefore not receiving the email, fails to comply. Would the owner return from vacation to find that their account had been closed, their land and possessions seized and their machine hash-blocked?
You can see from these few examples that there is no proper line that has been drawn by Linden Labs about what is "broadly offensive" and who exactly has to take responsibility for it. One thing is for sure, and that is that Linden Labs themselves don't want to be the sole responsible party - but where does the line get drawn? In a civilization specializing in shifting blame to other parties, would innocent accounts not responsible for the placing of "broadly offensive" content be as guilty as those actually placing the content? And are Linden Labs simply giving a free pass to anyone with a grudge against someone to pop over to that persons land, on a fake free account, and placing "broadly offensive" content so that he or she can get the person they hate banned?

Daniel, if you're going to ask the community for help, you're going to have to be far more specific about "broadly offensive" content; what it means, what it includes and excludes, and who will be to blame when it gets discovered. Yes, we all must play a part in keeping Second Life safe, but this isn't the way to inspire confidence. Don't be surprised when people don't use it for fear that they too might be warned or banned.

Friday, June 1, 2007

The discount that costs more than the original

So in preparation for voice being introduced to Second Life, they've partnered with a company to sell headsets, and are offering this "discount" deal costing a mere $80. One should note two things here, however. Number one is that this is the "featured" headset, meaning it's the most expensive, the one they'd love you to buy. If you click the "Selected Headsets" link, there are cheaper offers. Number two is that you can buy it a LOT cheaper elsewhere.

Let's look at some figures. All of the figures don't include postage and packing, but I have no reason to believe that the prices of other stores are vastly different.

The "discount" store has the Plantronics Audio 450 Portable PC Headset priced at $23.42 The cheapest I could find this for was actually from Hewlett Packard's store, where it was $17.28 - no sign of a discount here.

The next most expensive is the Plantronics Audio 370 at $36.82 - ZipZoomFly.com were cheapest for this one, at $28.50; again, no genuine discount in sight here.

Next up we have the Plantronics Audio 510 USB Headset: "Discount" price from Linden's partner: $46.87 - so what price can I get it for with a quick google search? $35.68 from TheNerds.net - three nil down.

Their next most expensive headset is the Plantronics DSP-400 PC Headset weighing in at a hefty $53.57 from the "discount" partner of Linden Labs. Best price I could find? $36.90 from Techonweb.com - can we make it a full house?

Apparently we can. As previously mentioned the "feature" - read "most expensive" - headset is the Plantronics Audio 550 Binaural USB Headset with DSP at a stonking $80.37. Quick search on that one and Mwave.com are the cheapest, at $51.91 nearly $30 cheaper than the "discount" offer from Linden Labs.

So I have to ask, Linden Labs - Where the hell is the discount you (or rather your partner) is promising? Every single headset they're selling is not discounted, it's actually more expensive than other retailers, in some cases nearly $30 more expensive.

This is false advertising. There's no discount. There's a backhander. We're being ripped off. And then they want to us to trust their choice of "honest" companies with Integrity for age verification?

No thanks!